Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

Journal of Science and Technology (JST) · e-ISSN 2456-5660 · published by Longman Publishers, Hyderabad, India

This statement sets out what the Journal of Science and Technology expects of everyone involved in publishing an article — authors, reviewers, editors and the publisher — and what happens when those expectations are not met. It follows the Core Practices and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the authorship recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). JST is not a member of COPE; it applies COPE's guidance as the standard against which its own conduct is measured.

1. The publisher

Longman Publishers publishes JST and is responsible for its editorial oversight, publication ethics and long-term availability. The publisher guarantees the editorial independence of the Editor-in-Chief and the editorial board: no commercial consideration influences what is accepted or rejected. JST charges no fees of any kind and carries no advertising, so no editorial decision is ever connected to payment. The publisher preserves the journal's content in Portico, supports the editors in investigating concerns, and ensures that corrections, expressions of concern and retractions are published as set out in the Crossmark Policy.

2. Duties of editors

Publication decisions. The Editor-in-Chief decides which manuscripts are published, on the basis of their validity, originality and importance to researchers and readers, guided by the reviewers' reports and the journal's policies, and within the law on libel, copyright and plagiarism. Every research manuscript is assessed under double-blind peer review by at least two independent reviewers before a decision is made (see the Peer Review Policy).

Fair play. Manuscripts are judged on their intellectual content alone, without regard to the authors' race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, ethnic origin, citizenship, institution or political views.

Confidentiality. Editors and editorial staff do not disclose anything about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, the reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers and the publisher, as the handling of the manuscript requires.

Conflicts of interest. An editor does not handle a manuscript in which they have a competing interest — including manuscripts by colleagues at their own institution, recent collaborators, or authors with whom they have a personal or financial relationship — and passes it to another editor. Unpublished material from a submitted manuscript is never used in an editor's own work without the authors' written consent.

Integrity of the record. When an error or a concern about a published article comes to light, editors act on it as described in section 6, and publish corrections, expressions of concern or retractions as the Crossmark Policy requires. Editors do not use generative AI tools to assess manuscripts and do not upload manuscripts to them (see the Gen AI Policy).

3. Duties of reviewers

Contribution to editorial decisions. Peer review helps the editor decide and, through the editor, helps the author improve the manuscript. Reviewers follow the Reviewer Guidelines.

Promptness. A reviewer who does not feel qualified to assess a manuscript, or who cannot review it within the time asked, tells the editor at once and declines.

Confidentiality. A manuscript under review is a confidential document. It is not shown to or discussed with others except as the editor authorises, and it is never uploaded to a public generative AI tool.

Objectivity. Reviews are conducted objectively and expressed clearly with supporting arguments. Personal criticism of the authors is not acceptable.

Acknowledgement of sources. Reviewers point out relevant published work the authors have not cited, and tell the editor of any substantial similarity or overlap between the manuscript and other work known to them.

Conflicts of interest. Reviewers do not review manuscripts in which they have a competing, collaborative or other relationship with any author, company or institution connected to the work, and do not use privileged information or ideas obtained through review for their own advantage.

4. Duties of authors

Reporting standards. Authors present an accurate account of the work performed and an objective discussion of its significance, with enough detail and references for others to reproduce it. Fraudulent or knowingly inaccurate statements are unethical and unacceptable.

Data access and retention. Authors may be asked to provide the raw data for editorial review, are expected to make the data underlying their findings available as the Data Availability Policy requires, and retain the data for a reasonable time after publication.

Originality and plagiarism. Authors submit entirely original work, and where they use the work or words of others they cite or quote it appropriately. Plagiarism in any form — copying, close paraphrasing without attribution, self-plagiarism, text recycling — is unethical and is handled as set out in the Plagiarism Policy. Manuscripts are screened for similarity to published work.

Multiple, redundant or concurrent publication. Authors do not publish manuscripts describing essentially the same research in more than one journal, and do not submit a manuscript to JST while it is under consideration elsewhere. Posting a preprint on a recognised server is not prior publication and should be disclosed at submission.

Acknowledgement of sources. Proper acknowledgement of the work of others is always given, and publications that shaped the reported work are cited.

Authorship. Authorship is limited to those who meet all four ICMJE criteria: substantial contribution to the conception, design, data acquisition, analysis or interpretation of the work; drafting or critically revising it; approving the final version; and agreeing to be accountable for all aspects of it. Others who contributed are named in the Acknowledgements. The corresponding author ensures that all appropriate co-authors, and no inappropriate ones, are listed, and that every co-author has approved the final manuscript and its submission. Changes to authorship after submission follow COPE guidance and require the written agreement of every author (see the Editorial Policies).

Research involving people or animals; hazards. Work involving human participants, human material or data, or animals must have been carried out with the approval of an appropriate ethics committee and, for human participants, with informed consent; the approving body and reference are stated in the manuscript, and identifiable individuals are not shown without their consent for publication. The requirements are set out in the journal's Research Ethics policy (human participants and animals). Where the work involves chemicals, procedures or equipment with unusual hazards, the authors identify them clearly in the manuscript.

Disclosure and conflicts of interest. Authors disclose in the manuscript any financial or other substantive interest that could be seen to influence the results or their interpretation, and all sources of financial support for the work.

Images and data integrity. Images are not manipulated in ways that could mislead; adjustments applied to a whole image and disclosed are acceptable, selective enhancement, removal or addition is not. Data are not fabricated, falsified or selectively presented. Generative AI is not used to create or alter images or data (see the Gen AI Policy).

Use of generative AI. AI tools are not authors. Any use of a generative AI tool in preparing the manuscript is disclosed as the Gen AI Policy requires, and the authors remain responsible for everything in the manuscript.

Errors in published work. An author who discovers a significant error or inaccuracy in their own published article tells the editor promptly and cooperates in correcting or retracting it.

5. Research with human participants and animals

JST publishes research involving people or animals only where it was conducted ethically. The full requirements — ethics-committee approval with its reference, informed consent, the Declaration of Helsinki for human studies, the ARRIVE guidelines and institutional welfare rules for animal studies — are set out in the journal's Research Ethics policy. Manuscripts that do not carry the required statements are returned to the authors before review.

6. How allegations of misconduct are handled

Who may raise a concern, and how. Anyone — a reader, author, reviewer, editor, institution or another journal — may raise a concern about a submitted manuscript or a published article by writing to the Editor-in-Chief at editor@jst.org.in, describing the concern as specifically as possible and attaching any evidence. Concerns may be raised anonymously; they are still investigated if they are specific enough to be assessed. Every concern is acknowledged within five working days. Nobody who raises a concern in good faith suffers any disadvantage with the journal for doing so.

What counts as misconduct. Plagiarism; fabrication or falsification of data or images; duplicate or redundant publication; undisclosed conflicts of interest; authorship disputes and gift, guest or ghost authorship; research conducted without the required ethical approval or consent; citation manipulation; undisclosed use of generative AI; reviewer misconduct such as breaching confidentiality or using a manuscript's content; and any attempt to influence the review process improperly.

Who decides, and how. The Editor-in-Chief carries out an initial assessment following the relevant COPE flowchart for the type of concern. Where the concern is not clearly unfounded, the authors (or the reviewer or editor concerned) are told what has been alleged and given a reasonable opportunity to respond in writing. The Editor-in-Chief may consult other members of the editorial board, an independent expert, or the publisher, and may convene a small committee to examine the evidence. Where the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, the publisher appoints another senior editor to handle the matter. Throughout, the matter is treated in confidence and the people involved are named only to those who need to know.

Institutions and funders. Where the evidence indicates serious misconduct, or where the authors do not respond, JST contacts the authors' institution (for example the head of department, the dean or the research-integrity office) or the funder, provides the evidence, and asks the institution to investigate under its own procedures. JST cooperates with such investigations and takes their findings into account.

Outcomes. Depending on what is established, JST may: reject or return a submitted manuscript; require a correction to a published article; publish an expression of concern while an investigation continues; retract a published article, with a notice that states the reason and who requested it; inform the authors' institution or funder; or decline to consider further submissions from the authors for a stated period. Corrections, expressions of concern and retractions are published as set out in the Crossmark Policy; the original article is never silently altered or deleted. The person who raised the concern is told the outcome.

Appeals. Authors may appeal a decision arising from an investigation, once, in writing, within 30 days; the appeal is considered by an editor not involved in the original decision, and the outcome is final. Complaints about the way a matter was handled follow the same route.

Records. The journal keeps a confidential record of every concern raised and its outcome.

7. Corrections and retractions

How and when a published article is corrected, updated, marked with an expression of concern, retracted or — in exceptional circumstances — removed, and what happens to the article and its record afterwards, is set out in full in the Crossmark Policy and summarised in the Errata, Retractions and Corrigenda Policy.

8. Review of this statement

This statement is reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief and the publisher at least once a year and whenever COPE's guidance changes. Questions about it go to editor@jst.org.in.